Pedal Genie

The service felt a bit limiting in that the top 3 or so of my list was very rarely available. I would have enjoyed keeping the service to continue trying pedals if I hadn't felt that somehow I was being "throttled".

hey I'm giving it 3 stars just because the price was a little too much for me. Plus I always wanted you guys to offer a payment plan option when I wanted to purchase the pedals. Everyone was very personable, friendly and helpful. Thanks

Its a good service, but the fact that I can't get the pedal I wanted at the time I wanted, is why I cancelled. Its easier to just take my guitar to a shop and play with demo pedals there. Please let me know if you are able to implement pedal-on-demand in the future and I will def resign up! Thanks, -Jayson

I think it's a great service for people who just like to try out new things and don't really care what they get, but if you are someone who is looking to try out a few specific things, the minimum 10 pedal wish list setup can be frustrating and undermine the utility of the service. A shorter list (5 maybe) would be more helpful, and would probably bring me back as a subscriber.

Great idea and overall a good service. The only problem is the wait for some of the more exciting pedals, which sometimes meant being sent pedals I wasn't so excited to try.